Cabinet members clashed over Wiltshire Council's financial position during a meeting at County Hall on Wednesday (18th November), with opposition leader Richard Clewer warning that reserves were at “basement levels” and council leader Ian Thorn telling his predecessor he should show some “humility”.
The heated exchanges came as Cabinet considered the latest budget monitoring report, which included a warning from the council's Section 151 officer that its financial position was “not tolerable nor indeed sustainable going forward in the long run”.
Finance cabinet member Gavin Grant insisted the administration would address the forecast overspend and deliver a balanced budget by the end of the financial year.
But Cllr Clewer, who chairs the Finance and Procurement Select Committee, said scrutiny members had been “extremely concerned on a number of fronts”.
He claimed available reserves had fallen from £51 million when he left the council leadership to £12.4 million, warning that the council was “burning through reserves at a scary rate”.
He also raised concerns about the Dedicated Schools Grant deficit, which is due to hit the council's balance sheet in March 2028, saying it could put further pressure on what remained of the reserves.
Cllr Grant acknowledged the potential impact of the schools deficit, saying that meeting it from reserves would cause “significant pain”. He said work was under way on a plan but that he was not yet ready to publish it.
The proposed use of £1.5 million from reserves also came under scrutiny, with Cllr Clewer questioning how the figure had made it into the report.
“Did anyone read the report? Did anyone question it?” he asked, warning that the error raised questions about what else might be wrong.
The recommendation to use the £1.5 million was subsequently withdrawn, with Cllr Grant confirming that the money would instead be placed back into reserves.
The debate then turned increasingly towards the record of the previous Conservative administration.
Cllr Grant referred to the £4.857 million deficit inherited by the Liberal Democrats, which he said had required an unplanned drawdown from reserves. He also spoke of an “unbelievable mountain of debt” owed to the council, which he said the current administration had been tackling.
Council leader Cllr Thorn also challenged Cllr Clewer's criticism, saying the previous administration had overseen an almost £5 million reduction in reserves after failing to deliver a balanced budget in its final year.
“I think there has to be some degree of humility when he launches into attacks on us in relation to the reserves,” he said.
Cllr Clewer disputed the suggestion that the previous administration's record justified the current position, pointing out that reserves had still stood at £51 million when he left office.
He also questioned the administration's explanation for the adult social care overspend, saying the previous year's monitoring reports had given assurances that spending was under control before a significant overspend emerged unexpectedly.
He said officers had still not provided clear answers about where the additional costs had come from.
“To simply say that we will sort it, it's all going to be fine, that's not a rational way to approach the politics of a council and the finances of a council,” he said.
Cllr Grant then challenged the accuracy of Cllr Clewer's own financial reporting during his time as leader, asking whether his previous quarter-three report had been accurate.
Referring to the section dealing with adult social care, he said: “I think it must have been a total work of fiction.”
He went on to say that the current administration had intensified its work with adult social care providers and was now into a second phase of that work.
Cllr Clewer continued to question how the unexpected overspend had arisen, while also challenging the administration over its confidence that the current year's financial position could be brought back into balance.
Cllr Grant maintained that he would not agree to the proposed £1.5 million drawdown from reserves and said managers and senior leaders would be expected to find ways to mitigate the pressure.
He said protecting and rebuilding reserves was a priority, adding that the council had put £3.1 million back into reserves at the end of the previous financial year.
He rejected suggestions that the council was facing a catastrophic position, saying that if it were, Cabinet would be discussing a Section 114 notice.
Cllr Thorn also defended the administration's record, telling Cllr Clewer: “You can berate us, or indeed you could praise us, Richard, which of course you won't do.”
Cllr Clewer ended his contribution with a warning that the council needed to address the problems quickly.
“You've got to sort this out,” he said. “I really hope for all our sakes you do, because otherwise this council is going to be heading into very, very bleak financial territory very quickly.”
The final Cabinet resolution recorded the council's forecast revenue budget overspend at £5.782 million. Cabinet approved the recommendations, with the proposed £1.5 million draw from reserves removed.
Want to know what’s on in Calne? Visit our local events page for listings and to find out how to add your own events for free. Follow us on Facebook, Twitter and Instagram to keep up with all the latest news. Have you got a story for us? Email editor@calnenews.com or contact us here.


